At City Mattress, we know sleep isn’t one-size-fits-all. That’s why we offer a wide variety of high-quality mattresses—but a few rise to the top time and again. Whether it’s their unmatched comfort, reliable support, or dreamy durability, these best-selling mattresses have won the hearts (and backs!) of countless sleepers.
Here are the top 5 customer favorites and exactly why they’re getting rave reviews:
1. PranaSleep Karma Elite 2 Hybrid Plush Mattress
Why Customers Love It:
Luxury meets innovation in this plush hybrid mattress, handcrafted in the USA. The Karma Elite 2 delivers cloud-like comfort with breathable, copper-infused natural Talalay latex that helps relieve pressure points while staying cool and fresh. Customers love how the high-density Everlast™ foams cradle the body without losing shape, and the individually pocketed coils with edge-to-edge support promote spinal alignment for deeper, uninterrupted sleep. It’s the ultimate blend of cooling comfort, contouring support, and durable craftsmanship.
Customer Highlight:
"I was very nervous about changing to this hybrid mattress. However, from the first night I slept great! I just sank into my spot and woke up refreshed. My old mattress was starting to give me back pain in the morning and it was gone. Very happy with this choice!" – Fran S.
2. City Mattress Callisto Plush Firm Innerspring Mattress
Why Customers Love It:
The Callisto Plush Firm from our exclusive Celestial Collection strikes a perfect balance—soft enough to contour, yet firm enough to support. Customers love the cool-to-the-touch cover and copper-infused foam that actively draws heat away from the body for a consistently refreshing sleep surface. With tri-zoned, individually wrapped coils concentrated in the center third for added lumbar support, and reinforced edge-to-edge stability, this hybrid mattress helps minimize motion transfer, pressure points, and morning stiffness. It’s comfort and support, elevated.
Customer Highlight:
"Both very supportive and also soft. I get support without sore shoulders or hips, thanks to the cushiony top. Worth the investment." – Kathryn D.
3. Aireloom Streamline Luxury Firm Mattress
Why Customers Love It:
Handcrafted in the USA, the Aireloom Streamline Luxury Firm offers the perfect harmony of plush comfort and sturdy support. Customers rave about the patented Aireloom Lift™, which creates a uniquely “floating” sleep sensation by allowing every layer to breathe and respond to your body. With temperature-regulating natural materials like ventilated latex, breathable cotton, and a cooling Tencel® panel, this mattress keeps you comfortably cool. Its individually wrapped coils and high-density edge support ensure low motion transfer and full-body alignment for restful, uninterrupted sleep.
Customer Highlight:
"It has been a game-changer for my sleep quality and overall well-being. From the very first night, I noticed a significant improvement in my comfort and support." – Barbara H.
4. Beautyrest Black Series One Extra Firm Mattress
Why Customers Love It:
Engineered for sleepers who demand ultra-stable, no-sink support, the Beautyrest Black Series One Extra Firm is a top choice for back and stomach sleepers. Customers love how the combination of extra-firm and high-density foams creates a resilient, supportive feel that relieves pressure without any give. Cooling technologies like AirCool® HD foam and Sleep Climate™ with TENCEL® fibers help regulate body temperature, while triple-stranded pocketed coils absorb motion for undisturbed rest. It's firm where it counts—and exactly what many sleepers need.
Customer Highlight:
"This mattress is exactly what I needed—firm, supportive, and surprisingly cool at night. I sleep on my back, and it's helped with my lower back pain almost immediately. The motion isolation is great too—I barely feel my partner move. Worth every penny!" – K. McKnight
5. Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-ProAdapt 2.0 Firm Mattress
Why Customers Love It:
Precision-engineered for deep, undisturbed rest, the ProAdapt 2.0 Firm delivers firm support with next-level pressure relief. Customers love how the ventilated Advanced Relief® material adapts to their shape for up to 20% more pressure relief, while the signature TEMPUR-Material™ responds to every movement and instantly resets—minimizing motion transfer and maximizing personalized support. The cool-to-the-touch SmartClimate® cover keeps things comfortable throughout the night, and the firm feel is perfect for sleepers who want a solid, supportive surface without sacrificing comfort.
Customer Highlight:
"I was diagnosed with sciatica several years ago and typically get out of bed in pain. For the first time since being diagnosed, I wake up relatively pain free!" – JC.
Ready to Find Your Favorite?
These mattresses aren't just top sellers—they’re sleep game-changers. Whether you want firm support or plush relaxation, these customer-loved models deliver comfort that’s been tried, tested, and adored.
Visit your local City Mattress store and meet our experts, book an appointment, or shop online to find your perfect match. Because when it comes to sleep, only the best will do.