What to do at the 60-day mark if your new bed doesn’t feel like a perfect match—yet.
You’re about two months into sleeping on your new mattress, and by now, things should be feeling better. Many sleepers are enjoying deeper rest, less stiffness, and more support at this stage. But if you’re not quite there yet, that’s okay.
Some beds take the full 90 days to settle in. And sometimes, it’s just a matter of making a few small tweaks to help things click.
The good news? You’re still well within the adjustment window, and we’re here to help you get the most out of your investment.
1. You're Not Behind—Some Adjustments Take Time
The break-in period isn’t just about your mattress softening. It’s also about your body aligning to new support. This is especially true if:
1) Your previous mattress was sagging or too soft.
2) You’re switching sleep positions.
3) You have existing back, hip, or shoulder pain.
In many cases, your mattress is working exactly as it should, even if it feels different than what you’re used to. Improvement often happens gradually over the full 90-night period.
2. Here's What to Try Next
If you’re still experiencing discomfort, don’t rush to a return. These small adjustments can significantly improve comfort and alignment:
A) Reevaluate Your Pillow
The wrong pillow can throw off your spinal alignment, especially if your new mattress is firmer or softer than your old one. Come in store and try a pillow that matches your sleep position and support needs. Your mattress and pillow are a dynamic duo - they work together to keep your neck and spine properly aligned. By trying pillows at your local City Mattress, you can find the pillow that works best for your body AND your mattress.
👉 Find My Store or Shop Pillows
B) Add a Soft Topper (If You Need a Touch More Plushness)
If the mattress feels slightly too firm, a breathable memory foam or latex topper can help ease surface pressure without compromising support.
👉 Shop Mattress Toppers & Mattress Pads
C) Check Your Foundation or Bed Frame
A sagging frame or unsupported slats can impact how your mattress performs. Make sure your base is sturdy, level, and center-supported (especially for king and queen sizes). Proper support also ensures your mattress warranty remains valid.
👉 Learn about Mattress Support Requirements
D) Adjust Your Sleep Position
If you’ve always been a stomach sleeper, a new supportive mattress might encourage a shift to side or back sleeping—which can take time. Try using pillows to prop or guide your position gently.
E) Use More of the Bed
Slight shifts in where you sleep help the mattress break in evenly.
3. Still Not Feeling It? Let’s Talk.
If you’ve given it time, followed the tips, and things still feel off, we’re here to help. Often, a quick conversation with one of our sleep experts can uncover an easy fix—whether that’s a bedding recommendation, a comfort layer, or positioning advice.
And yes, you’re still covered by our 90-Night Comfort Guarantee. It’s there for peace of mind, not pressure. Most customers don’t need to use it—but knowing it’s available helps you sleep easier while your body adjusts.
Final Thoughts
You’re almost there. Most sleepers truly settle in between 60 and 90 nights, and we’re confident that with a few final adjustments, you’ll be sleeping better than ever.
If you need guidance along the way, just reach out. We’re here to help you love your bed—every night.
Need support or have questions about your mattress?
Talk to a City Mattress Sleep Expert →