The City Mattress Blog

Mattress Pad vs. Mattress Topper


sitting on bed with dog

Source: Viorel Kurnosov/

Navigating the world of sleep comfort can be puzzling, particularly when it comes to mattress pads and toppers. Many people are unsure of the differences between these two bedding upgrades, and some think they’re one and the same. Yet, understanding these differences is wise for anyone looking to achieve optimal sleep comfort. By grasping the purpose, functionality and benefits of both, you can make an informed choice for a restful night’s sleep.

What Is a Mattress Pad? 

A mattress pad is a thin layer designed to lie atop your mattress. Its primary role is as a mattress protector to safeguard against spills, stains, allergens and even everyday wear and tear. However, it goes beyond just protection. A mattress pad can also contribute to the overall comfort of your bed by adding a little plushness and softness to an otherwise firm mattress. This combination of comfort and protection is what sets mattress pads apart.

Common materials used in the construction of mattress pads include cotton, latex and wool, each offering benefits. For example, cotton pads are typically thinner and quilted, and most are machine washable, offering convenience in maintenance. Latex and wool pads are inhospitable to dust mites and mold-resistant, thereby boosting the longevity of your mattress and giving you an environment with less allergens. If you’re looking to protect your mattress while adding a touch of comfort, a mattress pad could be your best bet.

down top feather bed

Shop Breathable Sheets & Pillowcases

What Is a Mattress Topper? 

A mattress topper, on the other hand, primarily enhances the comfort and feel of your existing mattress. Think of it as an extension to your mattress, a supplementary layer that provides additional height, cushioning and support. A topper can transform your sleeping experience by making a firm mattress plusher or a soft mattress more supportive, depending on your individual needs.

Mattress toppers come in various materials, including memory foam, latex, wool and down, each contributing differently to your sleep comfort. Memory foam toppers, for instance, are ideal for those seeking added pressure relief, while down toppers can add a cloud-like softness to your bed. Furthermore, mattress toppers can extend the life of your mattress by reducing pressure on its core components, delaying sagging and providing an extra barrier against stains. If you’re seeking a significant change in your bed’s comfort level or want to revitalize an old mattress, a mattress topper might be your optimal choice.

damask dot cotton top mattress pad

Key Differences Between Mattress Pads and Toppers 

When comparing mattress pads and toppers, a few differences stand out. In terms of function, a mattress pad primarily protects and adds a bit of comfort to your bed. At the same time, a topper can dramatically change the feel, being the answer to dealing with a plush vs. firm mattress or vice versa. The thickness also varies, with pads being thinner than toppers. Material-wise, pads are often made from cotton, latex or wool, while toppers are commonly crafted from memory foam or down. As a result, toppers generally cost more than pads due to their materials and thickness. The choice between the two largely depends on your sleep needs and preferences.

Shop Bedroom Furniture and Accents

Pairing Your Mattress Pad or Topper with the Right Accessories 

The right bedding accessories can further enhance your sleep comfort. Pillows, in particular, play a significant role. Various types, such as cooling pillows, can work harmoniously with either a mattress pad or topper to deliver optimal comfort. When choosing accessories, consider your sleep style, the type of your mattress and whether you’re using a pad or topper. Additionally, maintenance is key to longevity and performance. Follow the care instructions for your pad, topper and accessories to ensure they remain in top condition.

How to Decide: Mattress Pad or Mattress Topper? 

Deciding between a mattress pad and a topper requires careful consideration. Factor in your budget, specific sleep needs and the current condition of your mattress. Remember that a pad primarily protects with a touch of added comfort, while a topper can transform the feel of your bed significantly. It can be helpful to check out different pads and toppers in-store or online to find what works best for you. Above all, prioritize your personal comfort and quality sleep when deciding — it’s your bed, and you deserve the best.

Sweet Dreams Are Made of Both of These

Ultimately, deciding between a mattress pad and a topper largely hinges on your individual sleep needs and preferences. Invest time in understanding and assessing your sleep requirements — it’s worth the effort for quality sleep. The beauty of modern bedding is the variety available, catering to all sorts of comfort preferences. Investing in the right sleep accessories is a step toward achieving enhanced comfort and improved sleep quality. So, dive into the vast array of pads and toppers in the market. Your dream sleep is just around the corner!